Rank Ys Games

[Peytral]

RANK YS GAMES

WELL IF YOU INSIST

Origin > Oath in Felghana > Seven > Dawn of Ys > II > Ark of Napishtim > I

...

[Chaosblade]

I knew someone was going to post this. I just didn't know who.

Origin > Oath in Felghana > II > Seven ≈ Ark of Napishtim > I (> most games)

I have Dawn of Ys, but I haven't played it. Had trouble getting it working. Think I got by that issue, so it's just a matter of beating it now.

[321jassman]

Here's my ranking.

Origin > Oath in Felghana > II > Seven/Ark of Napishtim? > I

Never played Dawn of Ys so I dunno...

[TaleOfUnlimited]

Is Origin that good?

Mine is Ys Seven > the rest, since Seven is the only one I played so far. Planning on getting the rest today.

[sanddeamon]

argh, such an unfair thread XD hard for me to give my rank, but ill try XD
ys vs sora>Ys oath in felghana>ys origin> ys 7> ys 1 and 2 chronicles the rest would be from youtube watching like ys mask of the sun

[Peytral]

(> most games)

For some reason I smirked. Same here, regardless.

And yes, Origin is that good. The best, in fact.

Also, unabridged list including alternate versions and whatnot:

Origin > Oath in Felghana > Seven > Dawn of Ys > II Chronicles > Ark of Napishtim > I Chronicles > Ys Book II > Ys Book I > Mask of the Sun > III

[Chaosblade]

I wouldn't count Ys vs Sora no Kiseki. But I guess it's more Ys than Trails, basically an Ys fighting game featuring Trails characters and terminology.

I'd probably rank it lower than all the proper Ys games I've played, except maaaybe Ys I, but it was pretty fun regardless.

[CelestialBlade]

Oh son of a...

1) Origin
2) Oath in Felghana
3) Ark of Napishtim
4) Seven
5) Chronicles II
6) Chronicles I

Those are the ones I've played. And to give you a sense of relativity, I thoroughly enjoyed the entirety of Chronicles and I plan on replaying it, even if it's at the bottom of this list.

[Terro]

1) Seven
2) Chronicles I

That's it so far I know I started Chronicles II, but then I went back to working on more Pokemon as my main portable >_> When I do my usual Hoenn hiatus (because grinding on it suuuuucksss...) then I'll go back and play it more.

[Wyrdwad]

For me, it would have to be:

Felghana > Seven = Dawn of Ys > II > Origin > III (Shut up, I like Ys III!) > Napishtim > I > (Most other games) > V > Mask of the Sun.

-Tom